Fedi Hive Mind - What should software free of AI be labeled?
-
@mastodonmigration @Blender @redox
Looking for feedback from as many projects that decline to use #AI as possible.
@FreeBSDFoundation
@tulilirockz
@sharkey@sharkey.team
@Sharkey@shonk.socialWho else?
@mastodonmigration Ah yes, the browsers, thanks to the #Zirconium discord for reminding me!
Any others?
-
@mastodonmigration @Blender @redox
Something like this?
@mastodonmigration @Blender @redox ...or perhaps other colors would be better. Anyone may take the idea and improve it
-
At least initially it seems like it would have to be self attestation.
-
@mastodonmigration @Blender @redox I feel that there needs to be some definition what that should even mean? Not developed with help of some kind of AI tool? No AI features for endusers? No machine learning features anywhere in the software?
Good points!
-
@mastodonmigration Ah yes, the browsers, thanks to the #Zirconium discord for reminding me!
Any others?
-
@elduvelle @Vivaldi Does #Vivaldi use AI tools to generate any of it's code, tools, or anything else? What is the corporate policy? Unfortunately your code is not fully open so we cannot examine it directly, but I'd like to know the policy at least.
-
Fedi Hive Mind - What should software free of AI be labeled?
A decision by @Blender to take money from Anthopic, and a policy by @redox to ban all LLM generated code spotlights the question.
Other industries have used badging like Sugar Free, Low Tar, Alcohol Free, 100% Cotton, and Organic.
What's a good label for code that is certified free of any LLM generated code?
So far suggestions include: AI Free, Organic Code, Not By AI, LLM Free, 100% Human, No LLM, No AI
Thoughts? Ideas?
@mastodonmigration @Blender @redox
I fancy "LLM-free" or "100% human", or a combination of the two.Roops
-
Fedi Hive Mind - What should software free of AI be labeled?
A decision by @Blender to take money from Anthopic, and a policy by @redox to ban all LLM generated code spotlights the question.
Other industries have used badging like Sugar Free, Low Tar, Alcohol Free, 100% Cotton, and Organic.
What's a good label for code that is certified free of any LLM generated code?
So far suggestions include: AI Free, Organic Code, Not By AI, LLM Free, 100% Human, No LLM, No AI
Thoughts? Ideas?
@mastodonmigration
Or how about a hand?
* it's a stop sign
* people use hands to make things
* people can draw hands; ai for a long time couldn't, as we all know
-
@mastodonmigration
Or how about a hand?
* it's a stop sign
* people use hands to make things
* people can draw hands; ai for a long time couldn't, as we all knowHonestly kind of shy away from using 'slop' in this context. It is an incendiary term and tends to incite a fight. IMO what is better is something more positive or at least neutral that allows for organizing around the practice of keeping code bases free of LLM generated content.
That said SLOP is certainly a good term to use when criticizing slop.
Thanks for your contribution!
-
Fedi Hive Mind - What should software free of AI be labeled?
A decision by @Blender to take money from Anthopic, and a policy by @redox to ban all LLM generated code spotlights the question.
Other industries have used badging like Sugar Free, Low Tar, Alcohol Free, 100% Cotton, and Organic.
What's a good label for code that is certified free of any LLM generated code?
So far suggestions include: AI Free, Organic Code, Not By AI, LLM Free, 100% Human, No LLM, No AI
Thoughts? Ideas?
I like the sound of "Not By AI".
The LLM ones seem too specific because wouldn't that leave out image generation?
-
@mastodonmigration
Or how about a hand?
* it's a stop sign
* people use hands to make things
* people can draw hands; ai for a long time couldn't, as we all know@Carl_Gylling @mastodonmigration I've seen several indie authors label their books "human authored".
-
@Carl_Gylling @mastodonmigration I've seen several indie authors label their books "human authored".
Like that! Perhaps also "human coded" "human generated" "genHuman" or "human built"
-
Like that! Perhaps also "human coded" "human generated" "genHuman" or "human built"
@mastodonmigration @Carl_Gylling "built/coded with natural intelligence"?
-
@mastodonmigration @Carl_Gylling "built/coded with natural intelligence"?
That's good... Liking this brain storming session
-
@Carl_Gylling @mastodonmigration I've seen several indie authors label their books "human authored".
@viennawriter @Carl_Gylling @mastodonmigration Might use "ante mortem" as well, since slop does not even need the monkeys.
-
@mastodonmigration @Carl_Gylling "built/coded with natural intelligence"?
"Human Intelligence" "HI" "100% HI"
-
Fedi Hive Mind - What should software free of AI be labeled?
A decision by @Blender to take money from Anthopic, and a policy by @redox to ban all LLM generated code spotlights the question.
Other industries have used badging like Sugar Free, Low Tar, Alcohol Free, 100% Cotton, and Organic.
What's a good label for code that is certified free of any LLM generated code?
So far suggestions include: AI Free, Organic Code, Not By AI, LLM Free, 100% Human, No LLM, No AI
Thoughts? Ideas?
First rule of brainstorming is that there are no bad ideas, and the second rule is no disparaging anyone's contributions.
If you read down here you may find suggestions that are half formed, but may lead your thoughts in a new direction. That's the process. We are all friends here. Let's noodle this one together.
-
Like that! Perhaps also "human coded" "human generated" "genHuman" or "human built"
"Gen H" "Gen H Code" "100% Gen H"
-
"Gen H" "Gen H Code" "100% Gen H"
"Human Made" "Made By Humans"
-
Fedi Hive Mind - What should software free of AI be labeled?
A decision by @Blender to take money from Anthopic, and a policy by @redox to ban all LLM generated code spotlights the question.
Other industries have used badging like Sugar Free, Low Tar, Alcohol Free, 100% Cotton, and Organic.
What's a good label for code that is certified free of any LLM generated code?
So far suggestions include: AI Free, Organic Code, Not By AI, LLM Free, 100% Human, No LLM, No AI
Thoughts? Ideas?
