@emilymbender
> bragging about the size of your own balls
Unfortunately, social media users seemingly still fail to convey irony.
Anyway, I am really interested in what objective criteria distinguishes valid critical feedback from mansplaining?
I think there are obvious cases. OK. But the interesting cases are the non-obvious ones. As always, the question where to draw the line. And we should not forget that any discourse-pattern which is not based on quality of arguments but properties of the speaker (such as gender) can be utilized also for the "bad side".
I totally get that it is annoying to get tons of dumb comments and I am not surprised that they mostly come from men. Nevertheless, I think "reply guy" and "mansplaining" are problematic concepts in serious debates.