Okay, opinion needed. Should I A: obscure the spotlight to have more legible text, or B: incorporate the text into the spotlight but have it slightly harder to read?

[reimar@mastodon.social]

@designthinkingcomic B

[retech@corteximplant.com]

@designthinkingcomic WHy not do #2, keep the text white, but have the light cone be at 40% white in that area?

Or have it as a gradient, hitting full white just below the "hend..."?

[Guest]

@designthinkingcomic I prefer B, but people with some sight/vision issues might disagree ‍️

[gbrnt@masto.hackers.town]

@designthinkingcomic argh on principle I want to say go for the more legible option, but I really think you lose the spotlight look!

[der_mit_ph@toot.berlin]

@designthinkingcomic with that amount of text the left one does not work for me, although it is more legible. But with less text the other one also might work better and gain readability.

I still think the picture with the unobstructed beam works better.

[demiguise@bonn.pics]

Hm... B looks cooler, but I feel like A is the more sensible choice

[jonnyt@mastodon.me.uk]

@designthinkingcomic If you can do it, have all the text within the light beam and don't spill it over the edges into the dark. Or vice versa (though this wouldn't work as well), all the text in the dark areas to left and right but none in the light.

[jonnyt@mastodon.me.uk]

@designthinkingcomic (I don't like either A or B. B is difficult to read at the border of dark and light. A just looks wrong).

[far@furry.engineer]

@designthinkingcomic Tricky, but I'd go with B. It's a little less legible, but there's not that much text to read.

[sdussaut@mastodon.social]

@designthinkingcomic A without hesitation. Readability is the most important imho.

[jonquark@mastodon.org.uk]

@designthinkingcomic I find B a bit distractingly difficult to read so I'd choose A (but I have 0 design experience).

[n_dimension@infosec.exchange]

@designthinkingcomic

3. Contrasting outline over text to make it easier to read "stroke"

[aubrieta@social.tchncs.de]

@designthinkingcomic choosing between the given options: B

Because of the height of the textbox, you otherwise lose the integrety of the light beam.

Other option: Give the text a grey background using angled lines. This only done for the black areas should enhance the readability.
Additionally it is obviously not part of the picture itself, but makes for a more homogenous background for the text.

Edit: Tried my own advice and it does not work well when having a black/white setup. It works only with very fine lines or directly with a grey background, with destroys the black/white theme.
Hm.

[ninafelwitch@tech.lgbt]

@designthinkingcomic A

[diogenes@fuerth.social]

@designthinkingcomic I would prefer the first option with text easier to read.

[angelo@social.veltens.org]

@designthinkingcomic Main problem with B for me is the beam edges cutting directly through single letters, which makes it a pain to read. The switch between black and white for full words I find less problematic than that.

[designthinkingcomic@mastodon.social]

Another option...

[kampfdiestel@mastodon.social]

@designthinkingcomic
Its a matter of preference:
Some people prefer reading the text,
other just look at the picture and skip text.
If you want people to read the text, choose A.

[ninafelwitch@tech.lgbt]

@designthinkingcomic the best option.

[a_cubed@mastodon.social]

@designthinkingcomic
Can you reformat the text to fit inside the black sections?