"I just found out that it's been hallucinating numbers this entire time."
-
@cmthiede @Natasha_Jay in this case I thought what they're paying for was mostly plausible deniability and blame shifting when investors find out that the numbers you showed them were 20x better than reality.
@cmthiede @Natasha_Jay @jwdt hm surely the investors then pulls out the "due diligence" argument.
If you are so stupid to trust an AI and even more stupid of expecting other people to pay for that then surely you're lacking above mentioned due diligence and are unable to lead a company
-
@Epic_Null @Natasha_Jay That's bad, but honestly--switching to a new system without ever double checking anything?
Everyone involved should be fired, including the #AI
@Epic_Null @Natasha_Jay @davidr yeah it's a system failure.
the failure is so bad you need to investigate how such a bad decision could have ever been made and you need to change your process -
@Natasha_Jay
Well, AI for professionals & experts is a tool for the expert who is in charge and responsible.
The kind of use of AI described here is for *general public* AI, i.e. where the user has no idea how correct it is & shouldn't even have to care as long as it is reasonably plausible.
Professionals, experts & businesses can NEVER blame the "AI" for the hallucinations they take as truth.
-
@Natasha_Jay This part in the original post is fantastic:
“The worst part I raised concerns about needing validation in November and got told I was slowing down innovation.”
hxxps://www.reddit.com/r/analytics/comments/1r4dsq2/we_just_found_out_our_ai_has_been_making_up/
@Natasha_Jay @drahardja some people really don't grasp what innovation is. Randomly running in a random direction is not innovation.
Surely the same people think the luddites just had a dislike for looms or something
-
@sodiboo @drahardja @indigoviolet the reason I know of for breaking the link (by using hxxp) is when you don’t want to contribute referrer data to the linked site. Reddit doesn’t need to know we’re talking about them.
@sodiboo @drahardja @indigoviolet @maniaclives i usually just put a space at an obvious location
otherwise readers might spend forever looking for the mistake -
The only use of ai my company has successfully implemented is having it write emails to dead leads.
@NickBoss @Natasha_Jay
Oh jeez, is THAT where all my SPAM is coming from?!!?
-
@Natasha_Jay how did they caught it by accident? Isn't that one of the first steps you do with data to check if it actually works?
So they could have just hired some random who will throw dice and even that would be a more sound business decision because at least then you have someone who takes accountability?
All these people worked with the data and not once did it click that the data doesn't align with their previous data?Something about AI makes people turn off their brain
@taurus @Natasha_Jay Wait, "plausible sounding percentages" is not enough checking?
-
@Natasha_Jay This really is a major issue with #AI.
Even if you use things like #Gemini "Deep Research", it still loves to make things up it couldn't research properly. For instance, I once tried to use it for researching axle ratios of cars and every time I've repeated the same request, it came up with different numbers.
(It can come up with decent results though for topics where lots of scientific papers are available, like life cycle emissions of vehicles with different propulsion types.)
-
@stragu @Natasha_Jay No idea.
@stragu @Natasha_Jay @drahardja someone says its AI generated, maybe that?
-
@taurus @Natasha_Jay Wait, "plausible sounding percentages" is not enough checking?
@Natasha_Jay @goedelchen uh no perhaps one should actually check
you know... the things a business does since... ever? Since the invention of business you are having an eye on the operation
-
@Natasha_Jay "Flounder, you can't spend your whole life worrying about your mistakes! You fucked ed up. You trusted us! Hey, make the best of it!"
-
@Natasha_Jay @goedelchen uh no perhaps one should actually check
you know... the things a business does since... ever? Since the invention of business you are having an eye on the operation
@Natasha_Jay @goedelchen ah I think I answered too seriouy
may I advice using a /s when saying things the average stupid person would write non-jokingly -
@Natasha_Jay
Well, AI for professionals & experts is a tool for the expert who is in charge and responsible.
The kind of use of AI described here is for *general public* AI, i.e. where the user has no idea how correct it is & shouldn't even have to care as long as it is reasonably plausible.
Professionals, experts & businesses can NEVER blame the "AI" for the hallucinations they take as truth.@Quantillion @Natasha_Jay No, an LLM is a toddler that has been reading a lot of books but don’t understand any of them and just likes words that are next to other words, and then you need to be very precise and provide a lot of details in your questions to make it answer anything close to correct, and the next time you ask the same thing the answer is probably different.
But yes, the user bears responsibility as the adult in the relationship.
-
@Natasha_Jay Sounds plausible.
-
@Natasha_Jay
He he they are using randomization to make chat bot look more "intelligent"
See this:
https://towardsdatascience.com/llms-are-randomized-algorithms/ -
@Natasha_Jay Vibe work is not work.
-
@Epic_Null @Natasha_Jay That's bad, but honestly--switching to a new system without ever double checking anything?
Everyone involved should be fired, including the #AI
@davidr @Epic_Null @Natasha_Jay Fire the bloody management. They keep pushing for "use more AI". If you don't, you are considered to not be a team player, be obstructive, hinder the company and all these things.
-
@Epic_Null @Natasha_Jay @davidr yeah it's a system failure.
the failure is so bad you need to investigate how such a bad decision could have ever been made and you need to change your process@taurus @Epic_Null @Natasha_Jay @davidr but... But... That would lead right up to the board of directors and shareholders. These people are by definition faultless. The eminent purpose of a corporation is to extract wealth without consequences reaching this select group of shitheads.
-
I don't get it. How did people immediately trust AI as soon as our fascist techbro overlords ordered us to?
Most of our friends ask chat GPT for all their important life decisions now.
It takes extremely obvious fuckups like the Flock Superbowl ad to make people pause for a second. Usually, we gobble up whatever the oligarchs ram down our throats.
