Imagine being so bad at stuff that using an LLM makes you better.
-
@david_chisnall Imagine being so slow at walking that a car makes you faster
@hfalcke @david_chisnall I read somewhere that the average speed of a moving vehicle in Manhattan is approximately walking pace
-
@hfalcke @david_chisnall I read somewhere that the average speed of a moving vehicle in Manhattan is approximately walking pace
I wouldn't be at all surprised. In Cambridge (which has a tiny fraction of the population density of Manhattan), driving is usually faster than walking and slower than cycling (which doesn't stop cars dangerously overtaking bicycles and then pulling in sharply in front of them so that they can stop at traffic lights sooner).
-
Imagine being so bad at stuff that using an LLM makes you better.
@david_chisnall it's a big bell curve of beigification
On Beigification | BIML
Lets face it, beige has a bad name. Maybe it was the omnipresent Docker khakis of middle management 20 years ago, or may
Berryville Institute of Machine Learning (berryvilleiml.com)
-
Imagine being so bad at stuff that using an LLM makes you better.
@david_chisnall imagine not being able to be an expert in everything but being asked to do a 100 jobs a day.
I'm hating on what llm mean but maybe pont the critique at the systems and the owners of the systems.
Don't blame the workers for having 100 jobs and only knowing how to do one of them right.
-
@david_chisnall imagine that your job is so unimportant that llm results are acceptable
My job is important, but I fear that LLM results will soon be mandatory. My employer's senior management can't utter two sentences without saying how great AI is and how it's changing everything.
Ah well, it won't be long until I retire.
-
@Orb2069 Given the externalized costs of cars, it's a pretty good comparison.
-
@david_chisnall Imagine... being lucky enough to live in the era of Coding AI... to have the resources to use it to do many things you wanted to do, but couldn't before... but... you can't figure out how to leverage it in a way compatible with your ego.
@hopeless @david_chisnall lmfao is ego what they call not wanting to learn a programming language these days?
-
@david_chisnall Imagine being so slow at walking that a car makes you faster
@david_chisnall @hfalcke this dude 100% has chatgpt fuck his wife
-
@hopeless @david_chisnall lmfao is ego what they call not wanting to learn a programming language these days?
@0x00string @hopeless @david_chisnall Laziness doesn't need to be rewarded
-
@david_chisnall Imagine... being lucky enough to live in the era of Coding AI... to have the resources to use it to do many things you wanted to do, but couldn't before... but... you can't figure out how to leverage it in a way compatible with your ego.
@hopeless Indeed, it looks we are surrounded by absolute geniuses with exceptional skills in every possible task
@david_chisnall -
My job is important, but I fear that LLM results will soon be mandatory. My employer's senior management can't utter two sentences without saying how great AI is and how it's changing everything.
Ah well, it won't be long until I retire.
@CppGuy
yeah, unfortunately, it doesn't even have to work well to be a threat. LLMs are imposed on people not on merit but by AI-pilled management. -
@CppGuy
yeah, unfortunately, it doesn't even have to work well to be a threat. LLMs are imposed on people not on merit but by AI-pilled management.Right. My few experiments show that nothing an #LLM says can be trusted. You can write instructions telling it to express uncertainty rather than guessing, and then it'll hallucinate less, but not to the point where I'd want to use it for anything that mattered.
Unfortunately, a year from now, my employer's staff will be divided into two classes: people who use #AI every day and people who've lost their jobs. There's too much ageism in my trade for me ever to find another job, so my choice is LLMs or enforced early retirement.
I once knew an extremely capable and senior developer who took early retirement rather than be forced to do #agile, but I'm not rich enough to take a similar stand against AI.
-
Imagine being so bad at stuff that using an LLM makes you better.
@david_chisnall "Aspire to be Average"
-
@david_chisnall imagine not being able to be an expert in everything but being asked to do a 100 jobs a day.
I'm hating on what llm mean but maybe pont the critique at the systems and the owners of the systems.
Don't blame the workers for having 100 jobs and only knowing how to do one of them right.
IMO the OT offers systemic criticism.
There's a fundamental difference between Being Bad At and Not Being Qualified For, isn't there?
I feel the OT is more about a watchmaker Bad At watchmaking than about a watchmaker Not Qualified For gardening, thus blaming employers for bad policies instead of workers for grasping at straws.
(Besides systematically attacking middle management willingly padding their own qualifications with shiny LLM overachievement, of course.
) -
@hfalcke @david_chisnall I read somewhere that the average speed of a moving vehicle in Manhattan is approximately walking pace
@chris_e_simpson @hfalcke @david_chisnall must be awful for people who live in Manhattan
-
Imagine being so bad at stuff that using an LLM makes you better.
@david_chisnall Just dropped that quote into my company's #ai-fanboy slack channel. Boy, am I gonna get it!
It'll surely be some variants on "I Find Your Lack of Faith Disturbing" -
Imagine being so bad at stuff that using an LLM makes you better.
-
@david_chisnall Imagine being so slow at walking that a car makes you faster
-
@david_chisnall imagine not being able to be an expert in everything but being asked to do a 100 jobs a day.
I'm hating on what llm mean but maybe pont the critique at the systems and the owners of the systems.
Don't blame the workers for having 100 jobs and only knowing how to do one of them right.
At some point we need to stop giving workers a pass on doing Bad Thing. It has become normalized to the point that it is part of the modus operandi of their employers to externalize everything and be held accountable for nothing because no one pushes back on them.
Workers are the ones who hold all the power here but by continually telling them it's not their fault, that they're just part of the system, we're also disempowering them.
If not workers, who?
-
Imagine being so bad at stuff that using an LLM makes you better.
And also, imagine being bad at a task and choosing an LLM to do it for you, acquiring a dependency for life, instead of putting in the time and effort to learn how to do it, *when you have the time to do so*, like students do.
