Plus that argument makes no sense.
C
camertron@ruby.social
@camertron@ruby.social
Posts
-
"Compilers write code for you, just like LLMs!" -
"Compilers write code for you, just like LLMs!""Compilers write code for you, just like LLMs!"
Ok bro, tell me again how GCC is being wielded as a tool by the extraction class to take 50% of white collar jobs.
Protip: you won't, because you can't.
-
parent, /ˈper(ə)nt/, noun: Manager of all the shitparent, /ˈper(ə)nt/, noun: Manager of all the shit
-
Look, if you want to write some code with an LLM, fine.@kerrick So why is it any different when Claude is involved?
It's not really a question of ownership either, since humans can own things that other people (or computers) created.
The US Copyright Office issued a report a few months ago that said AI-generated works cannot be copyrighted. So legally speaking it's not even possible to own the code Claude produces either.
-
Look, if you want to write some code with an LLM, fine.@kerrick First of all, thanks for RatatuiRuby, it's awesome
️ Second, I should have been more specific. "I made x with Claude" is often two separate statements:
"I made x," then a few sentences later, "Claude wrote a bunch of the code."
If I write code with another human, even if that human is my junior, it's disingenuous to claim the thing you created together was something you made by yourself.
You would never say, "I made x" - you would say "Steve and I made x."
-
Look, if you want to write some code with an LLM, fine.Look, if you want to write some code with an LLM, fine. You shouldn't, but fine.
However you absolutely do not get to say *you* wrote it. You didn't. The computer wrote it for you.
If I buy a car from Honda, I don't get to say I made the car. It's the same principle.
We have to stop normalizing language like "I made x with Claude."
No you didn't. Better: "I paid Anthropic to write x for me."
The former is intellectual dishonesty.
-
There's this Calvin and Hobbes strip where Calvin's dad says that if we actually wanted more leisure time, we'd invent machines that did things more slowly, and I think about it all the time. -
There's this Calvin and Hobbes strip where Calvin's dad says that if we actually wanted more leisure time, we'd invent machines that did things more slowly, and I think about it all the time.Found it
-
There's this Calvin and Hobbes strip where Calvin's dad says that if we actually wanted more leisure time, we'd invent machines that did things more slowly, and I think about it all the time.There's this Calvin and Hobbes strip where Calvin's dad says that if we actually wanted more leisure time, we'd invent machines that did things more slowly, and I think about it all the time.
