Incredible.
-
Incredible. Every second paragraph in this article is lunatic nonsense.
One of the things I've long said about hiring is that you can always tell when you're talking to a junior dev who's going to be senior-staff or better someday. You can always tell when somebody was paying attention in the theory classes.
But good god you can also tell when people missed that day in gradeschool when somebody slowly went over "So, what is a computer, really."
@mhoye Don't worry, I'm pretty sure the text is extruded, too. I've never seen a "The pattern is clear." in a context like this on human text, but am encountering it unreasonably often in LLM generated text.
-
But my favourite part of this, bar none, is how it's everyone else's fault.
It's Cursor's fault, Railway's fault, maybe even Anthropic's fault, someone's gonna hear from my lawyer.
The CEO of a company running a stochastic stack without access control, data hygiene or backups is blameless and powerless. That's AI's real selling point, after all: It's Not My Fault As A Service.
"This isn't a story about one bad agent or one bad API. It's about an entire industry ..."
Or, maybe it's you.
I wrote the words "I confess, I did it, I take full responsibility" on a piece of paper. I was ready to turn myself in, to atone for my crimes. But then I put that piece of paper in a photocopier, and when I pressed the green button I learned something amazing. And what a weight off my conscience! The only question was, how did the photocopier manage to poison the Widow Bentley, drive over Baron Grimald, push the Duchess of Lockley out the balcony window and still manage to frame the butler?
-
@mhoye Don't worry, I'm pretty sure the text is extruded, too. I've never seen a "The pattern is clear." in a context like this on human text, but am encountering it unreasonably often in LLM generated text.
-
I wrote the words "I confess, I did it, I take full responsibility" on a piece of paper. I was ready to turn myself in, to atone for my crimes. But then I put that piece of paper in a photocopier, and when I pressed the green button I learned something amazing. And what a weight off my conscience! The only question was, how did the photocopier manage to poison the Widow Bentley, drive over Baron Grimald, push the Duchess of Lockley out the balcony window and still manage to frame the butler?
(Credit for the inspiration, where it's belongs, this is me riffing on Avery Edison's razor-sharp tweet from a few years ago)
-
R relay@relay.infosec.exchange shared this topic
-
Incredible. Every second paragraph in this article is lunatic nonsense.
One of the things I've long said about hiring is that you can always tell when you're talking to a junior dev who's going to be senior-staff or better someday. You can always tell when somebody was paying attention in the theory classes.
But good god you can also tell when people missed that day in gradeschool when somebody slowly went over "So, what is a computer, really."
@mhoye this is just … exactly the replit thing again, isn't it? from last year? https://www.pcmag.com/news/vibe-coding-fiasco-replite-ai-agent-goes-rogue-deletes-company-database
-
@adamshostack @mhoye I'm confused. I had to check the date. I am *very* sure I read the "the LLM deleted my prod and when confronted, it confessed!" story before. Roughly 6 months ago, maybe a year.
Ahh, here it is: https://www.theregister.com/2025/07/21/replit_saastr_vibe_coding_incident/
@henryk @adamshostack @mhoye only 2 deleted production servers a year, I can't wait for the model to improve and get to 1 deleted production server a month, I'm sure AI will get there by the end of this year...
-
Incredible. Every second paragraph in this article is lunatic nonsense.
One of the things I've long said about hiring is that you can always tell when you're talking to a junior dev who's going to be senior-staff or better someday. You can always tell when somebody was paying attention in the theory classes.
But good god you can also tell when people missed that day in gradeschool when somebody slowly went over "So, what is a computer, really."
@mhoye I think one important aspect here is that's not just this company. This is the entire industry you're looking at. Practically every decision maker who has little or no knowledge of tech is now fully on board this hype train. Every one of them and every company they work for is a prompt away from doing something unbelievably stupid and possibly fatal.
-
@mhoye I think one important aspect here is that's not just this company. This is the entire industry you're looking at. Practically every decision maker who has little or no knowledge of tech is now fully on board this hype train. Every one of them and every company they work for is a prompt away from doing something unbelievably stupid and possibly fatal.
@mhoye and for some companies it will be less bad because there's a measure of defense in depth, such as keeping actual backups. But the more decision-makers push this nonsense in every nook and cranny of the tech world, the closer will be to unrecoverable failure cascades.
-
@mhoye The parts that involves selling services to customers? Reasonable.
The parts that involve actually managing a computer? Glorious nonsense.
While trying to keep my eyebrows from physically leaving my head, I imagined little speech bubbles as I read that article:
"My business was deleted by the best premium model running on the finest of agents."
"Screw you, Poindexter, I don't need to know what a context window is."
"Claude's not stochastic, *you're* stochastic."
-
@adamshostack @mhoye I'm confused. I had to check the date. I am *very* sure I read the "the LLM deleted my prod and when confronted, it confessed!" story before. Roughly 6 months ago, maybe a year.
Ahh, here it is: https://www.theregister.com/2025/07/21/replit_saastr_vibe_coding_incident/
@henryk @adamshostack @mhoye I had the exact same feeling/memory
