What I find super annoying is the proliferation of auto-dubbing on YouTube.
-
@alda This has been such a pain. It’s bad enough that you lose the original voices but auto dub has IME been universally awful. Bad voices, often completely inappropriate, and full of errors. I keep having to turn it off again and again for each account that has it enabled.
@baldur The saddest thing about this is creators from "dubbing countries" that are attempting to use this feature to expand into the English-speaking audience but it absolutely misses the target.
Even if there is a top button on your shirt collar, it doesn't mean you have to use it.
-
@alda Did you ever have a male voice in english dubbed over with a female voice in english? At the same time? Slightly out of sync so the whole instructional movie was impossible to watch and I could find no way of turning off the extra track... It was either both or nothing.
@eq @alda Some years ago while learning Russian for work I watched a certain Russian comedy (The Kitchen) on YT. There was a certain male French character whose lines were dubbed by a flat voiced female speaker. Now, this is not a YT thing, it is how TV in Russia is, dubbing, but everyone's lines read by the same person, and all flat. German TV dubbing is much better, but that voice over in documentaries makes me unable to understand anything. Also, background noise makes me unable to understand the dialogue. I need subtitles even for films in my first language.
-
Dear YouTube,
EVEN IF I SPEAK ENGLISH, I KNOW OTHER LANGUAGES AND UNLIKE YOU, I WANT TO LEARN THEM BETTER YOU UNDEREDUCATED AMERICAN TECHBROLOGARCH CUNTS.
@alda weird cause youtube keeps giving me dubbed french on already english videos
-
@eq @alda Some years ago while learning Russian for work I watched a certain Russian comedy (The Kitchen) on YT. There was a certain male French character whose lines were dubbed by a flat voiced female speaker. Now, this is not a YT thing, it is how TV in Russia is, dubbing, but everyone's lines read by the same person, and all flat. German TV dubbing is much better, but that voice over in documentaries makes me unable to understand anything. Also, background noise makes me unable to understand the dialogue. I need subtitles even for films in my first language.
-
What I find super annoying is the proliferation of auto-dubbing on YouTube.
I DO NOT WANT THIS. JUST GIVE ME FUCKING SUBTITLES BECAUSE I'M FUCKING LITERATE.
@alda It recently auto-dubbed Barbara's Rabarberbar into English for me.
Auto-dubbing people speaking is horrendous, but auto-dubbing a literal song is even worse.
-
What I find super annoying is the proliferation of auto-dubbing on YouTube.
I DO NOT WANT THIS. JUST GIVE ME FUCKING SUBTITLES BECAUSE I'M FUCKING LITERATE.
@alda So this IS a thing. I thought I was losing my mind when I saw a video the other day...
-
What I find super annoying is the proliferation of auto-dubbing on YouTube.
I DO NOT WANT THIS. JUST GIVE ME FUCKING SUBTITLES BECAUSE I'M FUCKING LITERATE.
@alda at least you can tell YouTube which languages you understand somewhere in your account setting and those don’t get auto-dubbed which for me solved 80% of the problem
-
@alda So this IS a thing. I thought I was losing my mind when I saw a video the other day...
@alda Okay weird, I experienced this on my KodI/LibreELEC "TV", but on my PC this is not happening, it is not even a setting. Maybe because I did not select any preferred languages in my settings?
I am unsure how this works
-
@alda at least you can tell YouTube which languages you understand somewhere in your account setting and those don’t get auto-dubbed which for me solved 80% of the problem
@bix It actually doesn't work most of the time and that is the problem.
-
@alda
Another thing the Anglos do not get is that to non-Anglos English is the easier language. They think their replacing phonetics with (local) tradition amounts to "complexity"@DataKnightmare @alda anglos made translate in firefox. Anglos! Monolinguals! It's unuseful. Disabled on third minute and never enabled again.
-
@bix It actually doesn't work most of the time and that is the problem.
@bix Furthermore, subtitles are a thing. Subtitles. For people who know how to read.
-
@bix Furthermore, subtitles are a thing. Subtitles. For people who know how to read.
@alda subtitles are the best 100% agreed
-
@bix It actually doesn't work most of the time and that is the problem.
-
@bix It actually doesn't work most of the time and that is the problem.
@alda really? It worked for a while but a few weeks ago I noticed I got a few dubbed videos (YouTube probably forgot a few languages) so I set them again and I haven’t had a doubled video since (and I have, eh, 5 or 6 languages enabled now)
-
@alda It recently auto-dubbed Barbara's Rabarberbar into English for me.
Auto-dubbing people speaking is horrendous, but auto-dubbing a literal song is even worse.
-
HELLO? NO, I DON'T WANT A DEUTSCHE FERNSEHFUNK DOCUMENTARY ABOUT POTATO FARMERS IN SAXONY FROM 1972 TO BE IN FUCKING ENGLISH YOU ABSOLUTELY UNCULTURED HOODIE-WEARING JIRA-MUNHCERS.
@alda andere frage: link?
-
@alda andere frage: link?
-
@alda it is hideous. Watched a video the other day that was originally in Brazilian Portuguese. The autodub was completely disconcerting and made no sense because the original language was jokey and used loads of allusions. The English autodub was just a robot blandly reading weird literal translations of sentences without any emotion. Absolutely terrible.
@tommorris@mastodon.social @alda@topspicy.social Sometimes it will autotranslate English comedy channels into German and it kills the puns
-
What I find super annoying is the proliferation of auto-dubbing on YouTube.
I DO NOT WANT THIS. JUST GIVE ME FUCKING SUBTITLES BECAUSE I'M FUCKING LITERATE.
@alda I understand german and english. I watch *exclusively* german and english, because all the channels I've subscribed to produce videos either in either german or english. I do not need nor want to have german translated to english and vice versa.
It sounds fucking horrible, loses literally everything communication is supposed to transport and adds a minute or so to load times.
-
HELLO? NO, I DON'T WANT A DEUTSCHE FERNSEHFUNK DOCUMENTARY ABOUT POTATO FARMERS IN SAXONY FROM 1972 TO BE IN FUCKING ENGLISH YOU ABSOLUTELY UNCULTURED HOODIE-WEARING JIRA-MUNHCERS.
@alda following on the strength of "jira munchers" as an insult
