sure this is all very bad for activitypub but this is truly amazing content
-
@laurenshof @seachanger
That he's the person in all of this that got the deal to write the book on ap is just so emblematic of the world we live in -
@seachanger @jenniferplusplus everything is gender, protocol edition
-
sure this is all very bad for activitypub but this is truly amazing content
It's not amazing but absolutely frightening when a key figure involved in the evolution of #ActivityPub demonstrates such a level of incompetence.
-
@jenniferplusplus @laurenshof hard to find a single person more embarrassingly to blame for the failures of mastodon to meet the moment
-
@laurenshof @seachanger
That he's the person in all of this that got the deal to write the book on ap is just so emblematic of the world we live inYeah so true. Hmm weren't there five co-authors of the AP spec?
-
@jenniferplusplus @laurenshof hard to find a single person more embarrassingly to blame for the failures of mastodon to meet the moment
Specifically for Mastodon's failures ... I can think of another candidate (everything is gender, implementation edition). But for AP and "the Fediverse" as a whole, I completely agree. And yet for some inexplicable reason people still listen to him!
-
@laurenshof “it’s ok if you don’t get it”
@seachanger @laurenshof ick!
-
Specifically for Mastodon's failures ... I can think of another candidate (everything is gender, implementation edition). But for AP and "the Fediverse" as a whole, I completely agree. And yet for some inexplicable reason people still listen to him!
@jdp23 @seachanger @laurenshof I assume you mean Eugen, and I want to give him all due credit for trying to do better. I wish he'd started earlier, and I wish it was going faster, but he's been doing the right kinds of things for some time
-
@jdp23 @seachanger @laurenshof I assume you mean Eugen, and I want to give him all due credit for trying to do better. I wish he'd started earlier, and I wish it was going faster, but he's been doing the right kinds of things for some time
My main point is that Eugen's had light-years more impact on Mastodon than Evan. Even with respect to AP's less-than-completely-positive (cough) impact on Mastodon, Eugen could have supported LitePub et al back in 2019ish -- or some other protocol change. And Eugen could have prioritized support for AP C2S. AP was in fact an improvement on OStatus when Mastodon adopted it in 2017, but it was Eugen's choice to do an EEE strategy and let it turn into a millstone.
I agree that Eugen 2026 has grown a lot in some ways from Eugen 2017 and even Eugen 2022 ... it's really hard for a founder to step away and pass the torch and he deserves a huge amount of credit for that. On the other hand local-only posts still aren't in Mastodon, admins still can't easily change the maximum post length, the documentation still talks about how allow-list federation is contrary to Mastodon's mission, I don't think he's ever changed his position on Meta's adoption of AP being "a huge victory for our cause" ... so I disagree on "he's been doing the right kinds of things".
-
@seachanger saying that to CHRISTINE!?!
@laurenshof@indieweb.social @seachanger@alaskan.social I genuinely don't know either of the people (or that third person, either) in that conversation, even by name. And yet I came away with a very clear sense of who to trust on technical issues.
And it was not "I talk about this in my book" guy.
-
My main point is that Eugen's had light-years more impact on Mastodon than Evan. Even with respect to AP's less-than-completely-positive (cough) impact on Mastodon, Eugen could have supported LitePub et al back in 2019ish -- or some other protocol change. And Eugen could have prioritized support for AP C2S. AP was in fact an improvement on OStatus when Mastodon adopted it in 2017, but it was Eugen's choice to do an EEE strategy and let it turn into a millstone.
I agree that Eugen 2026 has grown a lot in some ways from Eugen 2017 and even Eugen 2022 ... it's really hard for a founder to step away and pass the torch and he deserves a huge amount of credit for that. On the other hand local-only posts still aren't in Mastodon, admins still can't easily change the maximum post length, the documentation still talks about how allow-list federation is contrary to Mastodon's mission, I don't think he's ever changed his position on Meta's adoption of AP being "a huge victory for our cause" ... so I disagree on "he's been doing the right kinds of things".
@jdp23 @seachanger @laurenshof
Ok, well, I'd rather reinforce good behavior -
@jdp23 @seachanger @laurenshof
Ok, well, I'd rather reinforce good behavior@jenniferplusplus @jdp23 @laurenshof no doubt eugen has has an enormous practical impact on mastodon but Evan is just such a sparkling poster boy for the absolutely shittiest and most offputting part of this whole world
-
@jenniferplusplus @jdp23 @laurenshof no doubt eugen has has an enormous practical impact on mastodon but Evan is just such a sparkling poster boy for the absolutely shittiest and most offputting part of this whole world
@seachanger @jdp23 @laurenshof
If I was forced to choose between all Evans or all Eugens, I'd choose Eugen in a heartbeat -
sure this is all very bad for activitypub but this is truly amazing content
@laurenshof I thought I was in a fever dream watching this play out yesterday.
-
@seachanger @jdp23 @laurenshof
If I was forced to choose between all Evans or all Eugens, I'd choose Eugen in a heartbeat -
sure this is all very bad for activitypub but this is truly amazing content
@laurenshof people inquiring about privacy/security considerations seems like a real trigger point.
-
@j0ebaldw1n Evan is one of the 5 coauthors of ActivityPub, together with Christine. He's also part of the Social Web Foundation, and is an active contributor to the current maintenance of AP at the w3c. the other 4 have largely left the work on AP (2 of them work on another protocol now), and Evan does most of the current work on AP
-
sure this is all very bad for activitypub but this is truly amazing content
@laurenshof @cwebber @evan what I really like is the openness of it all.
On the signing issue, I'm with Christine. I like Evan's viewpoint for social systems, but not for digital systems with "complex system" mechanics and active intelligent threat actors.
-
@j0ebaldw1n Evan is one of the 5 coauthors of ActivityPub, together with Christine. He's also part of the Social Web Foundation, and is an active contributor to the current maintenance of AP at the w3c. the other 4 have largely left the work on AP (2 of them work on another protocol now), and Evan does most of the current work on AP
@laurenshof @j0ebaldw1n and if you remember Identi.ca, the open source Twitter clone from like 2008, where the retweet button was invented, that was Evan too. He’s been doing the open source social media thing for a long time.
-
@laurenshof @cwebber @evan what I really like is the openness of it all.
On the signing issue, I'm with Christine. I like Evan's viewpoint for social systems, but not for digital systems with "complex system" mechanics and active intelligent threat actors.
@promovicz @laurenshof It's "entertaining content" for sure, but what it also gets at is not just the technical side of things, but the social one, and how we are caught between both, and our systems are the output of the conflicts between technical goals and social dynamics.
@evan is my friend, and I'm not super proud of that exchange, because I lost patience publicly, because this is a sore issue for me. But of course, you tear things back, and Evan and I had a nice chat afterwards, and actually have hung out quite a bit before and since, and behind all of that, both of us were going through things in our personal lives.
And yet the decisions we make in these messy social dynamics influence the kinds of technical systems which in turn influence the kinds of social systems we can have!
