Relevant to today's hand-wringing about jet fuel costs:

[jfmezei@cosocial.ca]

@chris Thanks for theresearch. I had been wonderding what happened to the project. I had seed videos of other efforts and always commented on Harbour Air being the actual first, but lack of news made me think that the stunt wasn't viable and abandonned.

[chris@mstdn.chrisalemany.ca]

the engineering article about the motors is super in depth, some of it way over my head, but they also compare the development of EV cars to planes and I get this... at least now... because it didn't occur to me:

Regeneration is great for cars!
Regeneration is a BIG NO for airplanes! Because if you glide and the propeller to regenerate power, you fall out of the sky.

so ya, none of that!

"Critically, one area the company worked hard on reducing was regeneration. At no point during flight, as well as descent, can the plane simply carry on under its own momentum while air drives the propellers to generate current. That would create a large amount of drag, and the plane would start to fall rapidly.

“Maybe a glider or UAV could do that, but not a passenger aircraft,” Armesmith says. “There are rules against it in aerospace, so we have to actively stop regeneration from being possible, it’s a fault we have to arrest,” Armesmith says.

“So, if we’ve either lost power or had to turn the motor off for any reason, the propeller needs to be able to windmill freely. We can’t have any electromagnetic resistance to the propeller free-turning owing to regeneration back into the DC bus.”

ya... glide good! fall bad! lol

I am very glad these very smart people are making it happen and a local company is right in there!!

magniX magni350/650 EPUs: 700kW Electric Aircraft Propulsion

magniX magni350 (350kW, 128kg) and magni650 (700kW, 206kg) oil-cooled EPUs with magniDrive 100 inverters power Eviation Alice, Universal

E-Mobility Engineering (www.emobility-engineering.com)

#BC #AirTravel #ClimateAction #ClimateChange #EndFossilFuels

[jfmezei@cosocial.ca]

@chris The explanation for the silence in Harbour Air electrification:
"programme despite a setback, revealed in 2023, that requires it to use Magni650s instead of less-powerful Magni350s."

My guess is that the test flight worked with single occupant, but wouldn't with passengers on board.

[chris@mstdn.chrisalemany.ca]

@jfmezei ya one the other articles said it had to do with both power and redundancy as the higher power motor also uses 4 inverters, each powering a section of the motor, so if one fails the motor can continue just at a lower power.

[amgine@mamot.fr]

@mediocratese @chris

Russia built rather a number of models studying ground effect planes. They are now producing them commercially to replace ferries.

All of the modern ones I have seen photos of have extremely short wings.

[amgine@mamot.fr]

@chris

There was a video a few years ago of a semi-dirig being marketed to extremely wealthy people. And a couple things stand out in my memories. The whole thing was electric - you do not need a lot of thrust if you are not overcoming gravity.

The second was 'sailing': the Zeppelins mostly used wind for their transatlantic flight speed.

But most important was the silence. They cranked the mic gain so you could hear the wind outside. The guy's breathing was louder.

[chris@mstdn.chrisalemany.ca]

@Amgine i would so love to try that out!!

[amgine@mamot.fr]

@chris

Me too. <BIG sigh…>

[amgine@mamot.fr]

@chris

Forgot to share this article from last summer, so about 4 months after the article you linked:

Just a moment...

(skiesmag.com)

I am looking for any news they got the magnix650 motor(s) at the end of 2025.

[amgine@mamot.fr]

@chris

This is the latest info I have found about the Magni650 - published today. But nothing about shipping them to Vancouver…

MagniX Launches MagniAIR Electric Engine for General Aviation | AIN

Air-cooled MagniAIR poised to benefit from MOSAIC rule

Aviation International News (www.ainonline.com)

[chris@mstdn.chrisalemany.ca]

@Amgine looks like a very small motor in comparison to the 650 being used by HA

[mediocratese@climatejustice.social]

@Amgine @chris
Interesting.
Thank you.

[jdlbt@techhub.social]

@chris Interesting article. Aircraft operation is quite different than cars indeed!

The main challenges for fully electric flight are power density (i.e. batteries) and safety of high voltage systems. With current battery technologies, fully electric flight will remain limited to small, short range aircraft.

You might be interested to know there is other interesting technology development work towards electric flight being done in Canada:

RTX’s hybrid-electric plane is one step closer to the sky

In a control room nearby, about a dozen people – some of whom had worked on the system for years – gathered and watched. With the click of a mouse, the power began flowing to their creation. That creation was an early version of the RTX Hybrid-Electric Flight Demonstrator’s experimental propulsion system for a regional aircraft. It will pair a thermal engine with an electric motor – and, the team hopes, tap into a new era of fuel efficiency for aviation. The project is supported by the Canadian federal government and provincial government of Quebec along with a range of partners across industry and academia. It also reflects RTX’s company-wide approach to innovation; it combines an advanced thermal engine from Pratt & Whitney Canada, a 1-megawatt electric motor from Collins Aerospace, and a 200-kilowatt-hour battery system from the startup H55, backed in part by RTX Ventures, the company’s venture capital arm. The goal of the project is to show a 30% improvement in fuel efficiency compared to today’s most advanced regional turboprops. The team also hopes the project will show what’s possible in designing future aircraft. “Pratt & Whitney is the quintessential thermal engine maker, and Collins Aerospace is the quintessential aircraft system supplier on the planet,” said David Venditti, Pratt & Whitney’s program manager for the demonstrator. “There’s no other place really in the world where we have all of those experts and resources coming to bear and developing a technology like this.”

(www.rtx.com)

[rueben@mstdn.ca]

@chris The last update I saw was from late 2024 (youtube).

Good interview with the project manager and a pilot. The interesting detail to me was that they expected the operating cost to be similar to the turbojet planes, because the have to retire the batteries after 2000-3000 cycles. However, that cost comparison was conservative and did not include the residual value of the batteries, or the current cost of fuel.

Also, seems that the regulatory challenges are almost as difficult as the technical ones.

- YouTube

Auf YouTube findest du die angesagtesten Videos und Tracks. Außerdem kannst du eigene Inhalte hochladen und mit Freunden oder gleich der ganzen Welt teilen.

(www.youtube.com)