New blog post: "Forbidding generative AI and LLMs on Pepper&Carrot"https://www.davidrevoy.com/article1129/forbidding-generative-ai-and-llms-on-peppercarrot
-
@davidrevoy @kimcrawley The question to ask is who are you trying to appeal to when you say you're "not against all AI"?
Are you worried someone reading post-2023 is going to somehow think you're referring to some predictive algorithm in use in hospitals 2016?
Anyone with even a vague knowledge of AI is going to know you're not, anyone that doesn't isn't going to even know to think that as "AI" to them means the shit we're all disparaging!
-
@kwazekwaze @kimcrawley ? I'm not trying to appeal others with my ideas on the topic, I just say what I think and do, unfiltred. I'm an independent artist with a comic project, not a doing PR strategy.
Also, FIY, in Free Libre and Open Source gfx, we have a library part of GMIC like nn_lib ( see 5.2 in https://gmic.eu/gmic325/ ), that is "neural network learning". It use small, ethical dataset. It's for making better filters, it runs local, etc... The nuance is for that type of projects.
You're trying to appeal to centrism fallacy. "I'm not one of those radicals who is totally against bad thing, I am partly supportive of bad thing, to be rational and sensible!
The planet can have a little destruction, as a treat!
I don't like to get all *political*. So when bad thing is destroying the world, instead of being on the right side of history and firmly opposing bad thing, I'm gonna not get involved and just let bad thing hurt people 'cuz it's just politics, you know?
Don't confuse me for someone with principles and a strong moral code!"
-
You're trying to appeal to centrism fallacy. "I'm not one of those radicals who is totally against bad thing, I am partly supportive of bad thing, to be rational and sensible!
The planet can have a little destruction, as a treat!
I don't like to get all *political*. So when bad thing is destroying the world, instead of being on the right side of history and firmly opposing bad thing, I'm gonna not get involved and just let bad thing hurt people 'cuz it's just politics, you know?
Don't confuse me for someone with principles and a strong moral code!"
@kimcrawley @kwazekwaze Oh, a Straw man. Ok, discussion is over.
-
@kimcrawley @kwazekwaze Oh, a Straw man. Ok, discussion is over.
I see no "straw men" here, only a coward who refuses to take a strong moral stance. The planet destroying torment nexus and the technofascists who love it aren't going to give you a cookie as you watch the planet burn and shrug about how you don't care.
-
David, I thought you were really cool. But it turns out you're not really against Gen AI after all.
@kimcrawley @davidrevoy Ethical AI is a thing. (See, for example, Neuro-sama)
Clearly what we're against is AI slop and blatant plagiarizing of artists' works. (Not to mention massive data centers poisoning the land, but that's a different topic)
So far nothing good has come from AI provided by megacorps like OpenAI. See also: Capitalism.
-
@kimcrawley @davidrevoy Ethical AI is a thing. (See, for example, Neuro-sama)
Clearly what we're against is AI slop and blatant plagiarizing of artists' works. (Not to mention massive data centers poisoning the land, but that's a different topic)
So far nothing good has come from AI provided by megacorps like OpenAI. See also: Capitalism.
There is no non-evil Gen AI.
-
@kwazekwaze @kimcrawley ? I'm not trying to appeal others with my ideas on the topic, I just say what I think and do, unfiltred. I'm an independent artist with a comic project, not a doing PR strategy.
Also, FIY, in Free Libre and Open Source gfx, we have a library part of GMIC like nn_lib ( see 5.2 in https://gmic.eu/gmic325/ ), that is "neural network learning". It use small, ethical dataset. It's for making better filters, it runs local, etc... The nuance is for that type of projects.
@davidrevoy @kimcrawley Yeah man, I know. The "well-meaning individuals" part was referring to you! I ain't accusing you of malignance.
Try this: Imagine a world where half the critical articles about bitcoin had the author ending with "now don't get me wrong I'm not actually opposed to all crypto. SHA-256 and SSH are actually super useful technologies".
A little weird, right?
-
@davidrevoy @kimcrawley Yeah man, I know. The "well-meaning individuals" part was referring to you! I ain't accusing you of malignance.
Try this: Imagine a world where half the critical articles about bitcoin had the author ending with "now don't get me wrong I'm not actually opposed to all crypto. SHA-256 and SSH are actually super useful technologies".
A little weird, right?
Well, he's got to play into the little trick Sam Altman chose when he came up with the term Gen AI so people who oppose the planet destroying torment nexus can get get pushback with "so you want the scripts that make NPC in SNES game do a thing when the player does a thing to be *illegal*?!"
Meanwhile, there is no agreed upon definition of "AI" in computer science.
-
New blog post: "Forbidding generative AI and LLMs on Pepper&Carrot"
https://www.davidrevoy.com/article1129/forbidding-generative-ai-and-llms-on-peppercarrot@davidrevoy This reminds me, have you seen this animation?
-
@davidrevoy This reminds me, have you seen this animation?
@yuki2501
aww, amazing. Thanks for sharing, I'll follow the author. -
@mangeurdenuage Idem, bonne nuit!
-
New blog post: "Forbidding generative AI and LLMs on Pepper&Carrot"
https://www.davidrevoy.com/article1129/forbidding-generative-ai-and-llms-on-peppercarrot@davidrevoy Your illustration is pitch perfect.
Go get 'em, Carrot!
-
David, I thought you were really cool. But it turns out you're not really against Gen AI after all.
@kimcrawley@zeroes.ca @davidrevoy@framapiaf.org hi sorry i'm wanting to understand your position on what counts as generative ai since im not quite clear on ur stance?
so uh in ur other replies u mentioned generative ai from before 2022 is distinct and u use genai only to refer to technologies from after 2022(year of chatgpt relase which i assume is why u picked it?). gpt-3 released in 2020, would you still condemn it and/or classify it under generative ai?
what about alphafold 3? protein folding model released in 2024 -
@davidrevoy This reminds me, have you seen this animation?
@yuki2501 @davidrevoy cripes
-
New blog post: "Forbidding generative AI and LLMs on Pepper&Carrot"
https://www.davidrevoy.com/article1129/forbidding-generative-ai-and-llms-on-peppercarrot@davidrevoy consider also adding AGENTS.md to enforce it! https://github.com/manyfold3d/manyfold/blob/main/AGENTS.md
-
@Poslovitch@wikis.world @davidrevoy@framapiaf.org I need to see that wallpaper!!
-
-
R relay@relay.infosec.exchange shared this topic
️
